The Real Witches of the Middle Ages

Medievalist Larisa Grollemond sheds light on common misconceptions

People dressed as witches parade down a square

Witches in Masks, March 3, 2019, Iryna Pustynnikova. Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license (CC BY-SA 4.0). Source: Wikimedia Commons

By Larisa Grollemond

Nov 29, 2022

Social Sharing

Body Content

Think of a famous witch—I’ll wait.

Where does she live? A castle ruin? A leaky dungeon? A forest cottage? Burning at the stake?

Those are common conceptions of witches in the Middle Ages, but they’re not necessarily true. Consider this a medievalist’s witch PSA.

Manuscript illustration of a woman in bed while two servants bathe her two newborn babies

The Birth of Esau and Jacob (detail), about 1360–1370, Master of Jeande Mandeville. Tempera colors, gold, and ink on parchment, 13 3/4 × 10 1/4 in. The J. Paul Getty Museum, Ms. 1, v1 (84.MA.40.1), fol. 29v

In the Middle Ages, people who practiced medical and chemical arts—usually women—were midwives, herbalists, and ale brewers.

Though they were sometimes accused of witchcraft by representatives of the Christian Church in the Middle Ages, brewers and folk healers performed essential and useful services. This was not magic the way it’s thought about today.

Fast forward a few hundred years. The 15th century was another story. This is when witchcraft became linked to devil worship and was treated as criminal heresy. A more vitriolic and wider-spread panic about witches took hold. And the figure of the witch as it’s known today began to take shape visually.

This image from 1440 is one of the first depictions of witches on brooms.

A detail of a manuscript with two witches on brooms drawn in the margins

Le Champion des Dames, 1440, Martin Le Franc. Parchment, 11 x 11in. Bibliothèque nationale de France. Département des Manuscrits. Français

It wasn’t until the 16th century that the image of the witch crystallized into that of an ugly old woman with a variety of animal companions, who consorted with the devil and engaged in nefarious acts.

These images helped fuel the witch hunts of the 16th and 17th centuries in Europe and New England that led to the execution of thousands of people, mostly women, on fabricated charges of witchcraft. But that is a story for another time.

The Fantasy of the Middle Ages

An Epic Journey through Imaginary Medieval Worlds

$29.95/£25

Learn more about this publication
The Fantasy of the Middle Ages book cover
Back to Top

Stay Connected

  1. Get Inspired

    A young man and woman chat about a painting they are looking at in a gallery at the J. Paul Getty Museum.

    Enjoy stories about art, and news about Getty exhibitions and events, with our free e-newsletter

  2. For Journalists

    A scientist in a lab coat inspects several clear plastic samples arrayed in front of her on a table.

    Find press contacts, images, and information for the news media